Help Insurance

Health Insurance, coverage types

Mental Health Coverage and Parity: What Your Plan Must Cover and How to Appeal a Denial

Your health plan cannot treat mental health and addiction care worse than other medical care — that is the promise of the federal parity law. But the newest rules meant to enforce it are paused in court, and two of the top-ranking guides published in 2026 still describe those rules as if they took effect on January 1, 2026. This guide gives the correct status as of November 2026, explains what your plan must cover, how to recognize an unfair denial, and the appeal steps — with their real deadlines — that can overturn one.

Published
Updated
Reading time
16 min read

Key takeaways

  • The parity law is still the law, and the 2013 rule still applies — but the 2024 rule's new requirements are paused and not being enforced.
  • All Marketplace plans must cover mental health and substance use treatment as an essential health benefit, with no yearly or lifetime dollar limits.
  • Parity covers three kinds of limits: money limits, visit and day limits, and the approval rules a plan uses before it pays.
  • If your plan denies therapy or addiction care, you have 180 days to file an internal appeal and 4 months after that to ask for an independent external review.
  • Fewer than 1% of denied claims are ever appealed, yet about 1 in 3 internal appeals succeed — appealing is the step most people skip.
In this guide
A woman in a therapy session, talking with a counselor in a bright, calm office.
A woman in a therapy session, talking with a counselor in a bright, calm office.

Here is the status in the first hundred words, because most of what is published about this topic in 2026 gets it wrong. The federal parity law is still the law. The 2013 parity rule still applies. The 2024 rule's new requirements — the ones that would have forced plans to prove, with data, that they treat mental health care fairly — are paused. The three federal Departments said on May 15, 2025 that they will not enforce those new parts until a lawsuit is finally decided, plus 18 months, and the Labor Department narrowed enforcement further on September 8, 2026 5 6. Two of the top-ranking guides published in 2026 still say the 2024 rule took effect on January 1, 2026, with no mention of the pause at all. That is wrong, and this guide starts from the correct status — because everything else in it, from what your plan must cover to how to appeal a denial, depends on knowing which rules are actually in force.

Mental health care is not a side benefit. All Marketplace plans must cover it as an essential health benefit — psychotherapy and counseling, inpatient services, and substance use treatment — with no yearly or lifetime dollar limits, and pre-existing conditions covered from day one 2. The parity law adds the second half of the promise: whatever your plan covers, it cannot limit mental health and addiction care more strictly than medical and surgical care 1.

What parity actually means

The law behind parity is the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008, known as MHPAEA. Its core rule is simple to state: if a plan offers mental health or substance use benefits, it cannot limit those benefits more strictly than it limits medical and surgical benefits 1. That comparison happens across six benefit categories — inpatient in-network, inpatient out-of-network, outpatient in-network, outpatient out-of-network, emergency care, and prescription drugs — and within each category, the plan's mental health limits must be no stricter than the medical limits that apply to most medical care in that same category 1.

Parity covers three kinds of limits. Financial limits are the money kind: deductibles, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximums 2. Your cost-sharing for a therapy visit cannot be set higher than the cost-sharing for a comparable medical visit in the same category. Treatment limits are the number kind: limits on days or visits, such as a cap of 20 therapy sessions a year when physical therapy has no cap. Care-management limits are the process kind: prior authorization, step therapy, and other rules that decide whether care gets approved at all 2.

One thing parity does not do, and this surprises many readers: it does not force a plan to cover mental health care in the first place 1. A plan that covers no mental health benefits at all does not violate the parity law. What forces coverage is the Affordable Care Act, which requires mental health and substance use treatment as an essential health benefit in non-grandfathered individual and small-group plans — including every Marketplace plan 1 3. Parity then governs how that required coverage is limited.

Parity also does not apply to every plan. It applies to private employer group plans with more than 50 employees and to individual-market coverage. It does not apply directly to small-group plans with 1 to 50 employees, except indirectly through the essential health benefits requirement. Medicare, Medicaid, and CHIP are not group plans, although Medicaid managed care, CHIP, and Medicaid benchmark plans must meet certain parity requirements of their own 1. Before you rely on parity, check what kind of plan you have — the rules that protect you depend on the answer.

What Marketplace plans must cover

Every Marketplace plan covers mental health and substance use treatment as an essential health benefit. The covered services include psychotherapy and counseling, mental and behavioral health inpatient services, and substance use disorder treatment 2. There are no yearly or lifetime dollar limits on these benefits, and a pre-existing mental health condition is covered from the day your coverage starts — the plan cannot charge you more for it or refuse to cover it 2.

Cost-sharing for mental health care also counts toward the same out-of-pocket maximum as all your other covered care. For 2027, that federal maximum is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family 10. Once your spending on covered, in-network care reaches that number — including what you paid for therapy, counseling, and addiction treatment — your plan pays 100% of covered benefits for the rest of the plan year.

The essential health benefits list is broader than mental health alone: it also includes outpatient care, emergency services, hospitalization, pregnancy and childbirth, prescription drugs, rehabilitative services, laboratory tests, preventive care, and pediatric services 3. That matters for parity, because the comparison at the heart of the law is always between a mental health benefit and a medical benefit in the same category. A therapy copay is compared with a doctor-visit copay, not with a drug copay. A limit on inpatient psychiatric days is compared with a limit on inpatient medical days. The category is part of the test.

The 2024 rule — and why it is paused

To understand the current confusion, you need the short history. The 2024 MHPAEA final rule was released on September 9, 2024 and took effect on November 22, 2024. For group plans, most of it applied to plan years starting on or after January 1, 2025 — but the most important new provisions, including the meaningful-benefits standard, the ban on discriminatory factors, and the data-evaluation and comparative-analysis requirements, applied to plan years starting on or after January 1, 2026. For the individual market, the rule applied to policy years starting on or after January 1, 2026 4.

Those January 1, 2026 dates are the source of the error in the guides that are wrong today. They describe the rule as if it took effect on schedule. It did not — at least, not the new parts.

On January 17, 2025, the ERISA Industry Committee sued, challenging parts of the 2024 rule as arbitrary and contrary to law. Then, on May 15, 2025, the three Departments — Labor, Health and Human Services, and Treasury — issued a joint statement: they will not enforce the portions of the 2024 rule that are new compared with the 2013 rule, for failures occurring before a final decision in the lawsuit plus 18 months. The statutory duties of the parity law itself, as amended by the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021, continue to have effect — only the 2024 rule's new requirements are paused 5.

On September 8, 2026, the Labor Department's Employee Benefits Security Administration went further. Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-03 says the agency will not pursue enforcement of the 2024 rule's new portions, and it narrows enforcement of the comparative-analysis requirement to three priority categories: blanket exclusions or separate limits that apply only to mental health or substance use care; medical-necessity standards and review, including prior authorization, concurrent review, and retrospective review; and network adequacy — the standards for admitting providers to the network and the methods for setting what they are paid 6. The bulletin is internal policy, and it states that it may not be relied upon to create any rights — but as a practical matter, it tells you where federal enforcement is actually focused right now.

The 2024 rule's new provisions are worth knowing even in their paused state, because they describe what the government tried to require — and what a future rule may require again. The "meaningful benefits" standard would have required a plan to cover a core treatment for each covered condition in every classification where medical benefits exist. The rule would have banned discriminatory factors and evidence in designing benefit limits. And it would have required plans to evaluate relevant data — such as denial rates and network adequacy — to show their limits are applied fairly in practice, not just on paper 4. None of that is enforceable today. What is enforceable is the statute, the 2013 rule, and the 2021 law's duty to write a comparative analysis — which is the next section.

What still applies today

Three things are in force right now, and they are the tools you actually have.

First, the statute and the 2013 rule. The parity law itself has never been repealed, and the 2013 regulation that implements it still applies. A plan still cannot impose a financial limit, a visit limit, or an approval rule on mental health care that is more restrictive than the one it applies to most medical care in the same category 1.

Second, the comparative-analysis duty from the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021. Any plan that imposes a non-quantitative limit — a rule about how care is approved, not how much care you get — on mental health or substance use benefits must perform and document a comparative analysis, and must make it available to the Departments or state authorities on request, and to any participant who received an adverse benefit determination for mental health or substance use care 1 4.

That analysis has six elements: a description of the limit; the factors and evidentiary standards used to design it; how those factors are used; whether the limit is comparable to, and no more stringent than, the medical equivalent as written; whether it is comparable in operation, including the data, any material differences, and the reasonable actions taken to fix them; and the findings and conclusions 4. If you ever ask your plan for this document — and the appeal playbook below tells you to — this is the document you are asking for.

Third, the deadlines. A plan must hand over the comparative analysis within 10 business days of a request, or longer if the Secretary allows. If more information is needed, the plan gets 10 more business days. After an initial finding of noncompliance, the plan has 45 calendar days to state its corrective actions, and 7 business days after a final noncompliance determination to notify the participants affected 4. These deadlines are your leverage: a plan that cannot produce the analysis on time is a plan with a problem.

A person reading a health insurance denial letter at a desk, with a phone and notebook nearby.
A person reading a health insurance denial letter at a desk, with a phone and notebook nearby.

How to spot a parity problem

Most parity violations are not announced. They show up as small, ordinary-seeming differences between how your plan treats a therapy appointment and how it treats a doctor's appointment. The technical name for the rules behind those differences is "non-quantitative treatment limitation," usually shortened to NQTL. In one sentence: an NQTL is a rule about how care is approved, not how much care you get — like needing approval first, or the plan paying therapists less than other doctors, so few therapists accept your insurance 1 4.

Here are the patterns that should make you ask questions:

Prior authorization that applies to one side only. Your plan requires approval before it pays for therapy sessions, but a comparable outpatient medical visit — say, a visit to a specialist — needs no approval. Prior authorization is a care-management limit, and parity requires the same process and standards on both sides 2.

A visit cap with no medical equivalent. Your plan covers 20 therapy sessions a year and no more, while physical therapy — a comparable outpatient service — has no visit cap. Quantitative limits are numbers, and the numbers must be comparable within the category 1.

A network with no one in it. You call twenty in-network therapists and none is taking new patients, or the nearest one is 40 miles away. Network adequacy is now one of the three federal enforcement priorities, and it covers both the standards for admitting providers and the methods for setting what they are paid 6. A network that exists on paper but not in practice is a parity problem, not just bad luck.

Reimbursement that drives providers away. Your plan pays therapists far less than it pays other specialists for a comparable session, so therapists leave the network. This is also a network-adequacy issue, and it is one of the three priorities the Labor Department named 6.

Step therapy for addiction care. Your plan requires you to try a cheaper treatment and fail before it covers the treatment your doctor recommended — but does not impose the same requirement on comparable medical care. Step therapy is an NQTL, and it must be applied no more strictly to mental health and substance use care than to medical care 1.

None of these patterns proves a violation by itself. A plan may have a legitimate reason for a difference — different costs, different clinical evidence, different settings. That is exactly what the comparative analysis is for: the plan must be able to show, with its factors, its evidence, and its data, that the difference is justified. If it cannot show that, you have the beginning of a case.

The appeal playbook, step by step

If your plan denies mental health or addiction care, do not accept the denial as the last word. The appeal process has fixed deadlines, and the numbers show it works far more often than people expect. Here is the playbook, in order.

Step 1: Get the denial in writing, with the exact reason and the criteria used. Every denial notice must state why the care was denied and what criteria the plan applied. Keep that letter. If the denial came by phone, ask for it in writing. You need the reason — "not medically necessary," "prior authorization required," "out of network" — because your appeal answers that reason specifically.

Step 2: Ask the plan, in writing, for its comparative analysis and its medical-necessity criteria. If the denial rests on a rule about how care is approved — prior authorization, step therapy, a network standard — the plan owes you the comparative analysis that justifies that rule, and it must produce it within 10 business days of your request 4. Also ask for the medical-necessity criteria it used to judge your care. A plan that cannot produce either document has weakened its own position.

Step 3: File an internal appeal within 180 days. You have 180 days — 6 months — from the day you receive the denial notice to ask your plan to reconsider 7. Include a letter from your therapist or doctor explaining why the care is medically necessary, and point to the specific comparison: the medical service in the same category that does not face the same limit. The plan must decide within 30 days if you have not yet received the service, or 60 days if you already received it. Urgent cases must be decided as fast as your condition requires, and at least within 4 business days, with written notice within 48 hours 7.

Step 4: If the internal appeal is denied, ask for an external review within 4 months. An external review is decided by an independent reviewer, not by your plan, and the insurer is required by law to accept the reviewer's decision 8. You must send a written request within 4 months of the final denial notice. The standard decision comes within 45 days; an expedited decision, for urgent cases, comes within 72 hours 8. Under the process run by the Department of Health and Human Services there is no charge; otherwise the most you can be charged is $25 per review. The HHS process can be reached at 1-888-866-6205 or ferp@maximus.com 8.

Step 5: In urgent cases, run both at the same time. If waiting could seriously harm your health, you can ask for an internal appeal and an external review simultaneously, rather than waiting for one to finish before starting the other.

One deadline is different and easy to confuse with the others: if you are appealing a Marketplace decision itself — for example, a denied Special Enrollment Period or denied tax credits — you have 90 days from the Eligibility Notice. That is a Marketplace appeal, not a claim appeal, and it runs on its own clock.

The numbers: most people never appeal

The case for appealing is not theory. It is arithmetic. In 2024, HealthCare.gov plans denied 19% of in-network claims — about 85 million of 451 million — and 37% of out-of-network claims. Fewer than 1% of denials were ever appealed: at least 262,982 internal appeals. Of those, 66% were upheld — meaning the plan's denial stood — but that also means about 1 in 3 internal appeals succeeded, and at least 5,881 external appeals followed 9.

Two scope warnings matter here. First, those figures cover all claim types on HealthCare.gov plans, not mental health claims specifically — insurers do not report which services were denied, so nobody can say what share of the 19% was therapy. Do not let anyone tell you "19% of therapy claims are denied," because that number does not exist. Second, the figures cover post-service claims only. They exclude prior-authorization denials — the kind of denial that stops care before it starts — and they exclude state-run exchanges, employer plans, Medicare, and Medicaid 9.

The public mood matches the data. In a January 2026 poll, 66% of insured adults said delays and denials of care are a major problem, and 33% said they had a service or medication denied in the past two years 9. The most common reasons for denials in the 2024 data were "other" at 36%, administrative reasons at 25%, lack of prior authorization or referral at 9%, and lack of medical necessity at 5% 9.

What parity does not do

Honesty about the limits of the law matters as much as knowing your rights. Parity does not guarantee that therapy is covered. It does not set your copay. It does not decide how many sessions you need. It says only that whatever limits your plan applies to mental health care must be no stricter than the limits it applies to comparable medical care 1.

Parity also does not apply to every plan, and state enforcement varies. States may enforce parity more strictly than the federal pause, and some do. If your plan is regulated by your state, your state department of insurance is a second place to complain, and it may move faster than the federal process.

If you need help, two federal lines exist. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services runs a parity help line at 1-877-267-2323, extension 6-1565, and can be reached by email at phig@cms.hhs.gov. The Labor Department's Employee Benefits Security Administration can be reached at 1-866-444-3272 1. Either can tell you whether your plan is covered by the federal parity rules and where to file a complaint.

A counselor and a client shaking hands at the end of a session in a warm office.
A counselor and a client shaking hands at the end of a session in a warm office.

Verified against the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the U.S. Department of Labor on November 19, 2026.

The bottom line

The parity law is still the law, and the 2013 rule still applies — but the 2024 rule's new requirements are paused and not being enforced, and any guide that says they took effect on January 1, 2026 is wrong. What is in force today is the statute itself, the 2013 rule, and the 2021 law's duty for plans to write a comparative analysis of every approval rule they impose on mental health and addiction care. Every Marketplace plan must cover psychotherapy, inpatient mental health care, and substance use treatment with no dollar limits, and your cost-sharing for that care counts toward the same out-of-pocket maximum as the rest of your care. If your plan denies care, get the denial in writing, ask for the comparative analysis, file an internal appeal within 180 days, and if that fails, ask for an external review within 4 months — the reviewer is independent, the insurer must accept the decision, and about 1 in 3 internal appeals succeed. Most people never appeal at all. Do not be one of them.

Frequently asked questions

Does my health insurance have to cover therapy?
If you have a Marketplace plan, yes. All Marketplace plans must cover mental health and substance use treatment as an essential health benefit, including psychotherapy and counseling, inpatient mental health care, and substance use treatment. There are no yearly or lifetime dollar limits, pre-existing mental health conditions are covered from day one, and you cannot be charged more because of them. The parity law itself does not force a plan to cover mental health care at all — but the Affordable Care Act requires it in Marketplace plans.
What is mental health parity?
Parity means your plan cannot limit mental health and substance use benefits more strictly than it limits medical and surgical benefits. It covers three kinds of limits: financial limits like deductibles and copays, treatment limits like the number of visits, and care-management rules like prior authorization. The rule comes from the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008, and it still applies today.
Did the 2024 parity rule take effect on January 1, 2026?
No — not as written. The 2024 rule was issued in September 2024, but on May 15, 2025 the three federal Departments said they will not enforce the parts that are new compared with the 2013 rule, until a final decision in the lawsuit ERIC v. HHS plus 18 months. In September 2026 the Labor Department narrowed enforcement further to three priority areas. Two top-ranking 2026 guides still describe the 2024 rule as if it took effect on January 1, 2026 — that is wrong.
How long do I have to appeal a denied therapy claim?
You have 180 days — 6 months — from the day you receive the denial notice to file an internal appeal with your plan. The plan must decide within 30 days if you have not yet received the service, or 60 days if you already received it. Urgent cases must be decided as fast as your condition requires, and at least within 4 business days. If the internal appeal is denied, you have 4 months to ask for an external review by an independent reviewer, whose decision the insurer must accept.
What is a non-quantitative treatment limitation?
It is a rule about how care is approved, not how much care you get — things like requiring prior authorization, step therapy, or setting the pay rates that decide whether therapists join the network. The law says a plan must use the same process and the same standards for mental health care as for medical care, and apply them no more strictly. A plan that demands prior authorization for therapy but not for a comparable doctor visit may be breaking the parity rule.
What should I do first if my plan denies mental health care?
Get the denial in writing, with the exact reason and the criteria the plan used. Then ask the plan in writing for its comparative analysis of the rule it applied, and for the medical-necessity criteria. File your internal appeal within 180 days, with a letter from your therapist or doctor explaining why the care is medically necessary. If that appeal is denied, ask for an external review within 4 months — the reviewer is independent, and the insurer must accept the decision.

Sources

Numbers in the text point to these publications. Links open the original source.

  1. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA)
  2. HealthCare.gov. Mental health and substance abuse health coverage options
  3. HealthCare.gov. What Marketplace health insurance plans cover
  4. U.S. Department of Labor, EBSA. Fact Sheet: Final Rules under the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA)
  5. U.S. Department of Labor / HHS / Treasury. Statement Regarding Enforcement of the Final Rule on Requirements Related to the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act
  6. U.S. Department of Labor, EBSA. Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2026-03: Guiding Principles for EBSA's Enforcement of MHPAEA's NQTL Requirements
  7. HealthCare.gov. Internal appeals
  8. HealthCare.gov. External Review
  9. KFF. Claims Denials and Appeals in ACA Marketplace Plans in 2024
  10. HealthCare.gov (CMS). Out-of-pocket maximum/limit — Glossary

Back to the main health insurance guide

This guide is general educational information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Insurance rules and prices vary by state, company and personal circumstances. Confirm anything important with your state insurance department or a licensed professional. Read the full disclaimer.