Help Insurance

Health Insurance, coverage types

Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare: the choice is really about three questions

Most comparisons of Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare drown you in premiums and plan types. The choice is simpler than that. It comes down to three questions — and the answers are different for almost everyone.

Published
Updated
Reading time
16 min read

Key takeaways

  • In 2026, 55% of eligible Medicare beneficiaries are in Medicare Advantage — 35.2 million people — and the share keeps growing.
  • Medicare Advantage caps your yearly medical spending at $9,250 in-network in 2026. Original Medicare has no cap at all.
  • You pay the $202.90 Part B premium on both paths. Most Medicare Advantage enrollees pay no plan premium on top of it.
  • Original Medicare lets you see any doctor who takes Medicare, anywhere in the country, usually without referrals or prior authorization. Medicare Advantage plans use networks and may require both.
  • Your one-time six-month Medigap open enrollment window starts when you turn 65 and join Part B. Once it closes, insurers in most states can deny you or charge more — and that door may not reopen.
In this guide
An older couple walking together on a tree-lined path in a park, smiling.
An older couple walking together on a tree-lined path in a park, smiling.

More than half of the people on Medicare now choose Medicare Advantage. In 2026, 55 percent of eligible beneficiaries — 35.2 million out of 64.2 million people with both Parts A and B — are in a Medicare Advantage plan, up from just 19 percent in 2007 3. The other roughly 29 million are in Original Medicare. Almost everyone on Medicare has to make this choice, usually more than once.

This guide does not re-explain what Parts A, B, C, and D are — our Medicare basics guide covers them, with the 2026 costs and enrollment windows. This article goes deeper on the decision itself: what each path costs in a good year and a bad year, what you give up for a lower premium, and the one door that closes behind you if you wait too long to decide.

The choice is really about three questions. First, how bad could a bad year get? Second, do your doctors and drugs fit inside a network, and can you live with prior authorization? Third, are you closing the Medigap door? Answer those three honestly, and the right path usually becomes clear. The rest of this guide puts real 2026 numbers behind them.

The 60-second answer

Medicare Advantage usually wins on monthly cash: most enrollees pay nothing beyond the Part B premium, the plan caps what you can spend in a year, and it adds dental, vision, and hearing benefits that Original Medicare does not cover. Original Medicare usually wins on freedom and predictability: you can see any doctor who takes Medicare anywhere in the country, usually with no referral and no prior authorization, and a Medigap policy can cover almost everything Parts A and B leave behind — if you buy it at the right time.

The 2026 costs, side by side

You pay the Part B premium on both paths. The standard Part B premium in 2026 is $202.90 a month, or $2,434.80 a year, up $17.90 from $185.00 in 2025 1. That increase is the first cost fact to get right: several comparison sites still show $185 as the 2026 premium. The Part B deductible is $283 a year, up from $257 1. Higher-income beneficiaries pay a surcharge on top: in 2026 total Part B premiums range from $284.10 to $689.90 a month, starting at modified adjusted gross income above $109,000 for one person and $218,000 for a couple filing jointly 5.

The Part A hospital deductible in 2026 is $1,736 per benefit period, up $60 from 2025 1. A long hospital stay costs $434 a day for days 61 to 90 and $868 a day for lifetime reserve days, and a skilled nursing facility stay costs $217 a day for days 21 to 100. Most people pay no Part A premium, but with 30 to 39 quarters of Medicare-covered work it is $311 a month, and with fewer than 30 quarters it is $565 a month 1.

Cost in 2026 Original Medicare Medicare Advantage
Part B premium $202.90 a month $202.90 a month
Plan premium beyond Part B None — but you pay separately for Part D and Medigap Often $0; CMS projects an average of $14.00 a month across all plans, while the enrollment-weighted average supplemental premium among drug-plan enrollees is $15 a month
Part B deductible $283 a year Varies by plan; often $0 or lower
Part B coinsurance Usually 20% of the Medicare-approved amount Copays set by the plan, often a flat dollar amount per visit
Annual out-of-pocket maximum for medical care None Capped by law at $9,250 in-network and $13,900 combined in 2026; average plan limit is $5,421 in-network
Prescription drug coverage Separate Part D plan needed Usually included
Dental, vision, hearing Not covered Usually included

The two premium averages in that table measure different things, and confusing them is one of the most common errors in Medicare comparisons. CMS projected the average monthly premium across all Medicare Advantage plans at about $14.00 in 2026, down from $16.40 in 2025 4 — an average across every plan on the market, including plans almost nobody joins. KFF's figure of $15 a month is the enrollment-weighted average supplemental premium among people actually enrolled in Medicare Advantage drug plans 4. Both are correct. The number that matters most to you is simpler: 75 percent of Medicare Advantage drug-plan enrollees pay no premium beyond Part B at all, and 98 percent of beneficiaries have access to a $0-premium plan 4.

Drug coverage is where the paths split again. Most Medicare Advantage plans include Part D drug coverage; in Original Medicare, you buy a separate Part D plan. CMS projects the average total Part D premium for Medicare Advantage drug plans at $11.50 a month in 2026 after rebates, down from $13.32 in 2025, while a stand-alone Part D plan is projected at $34.50 2. KFF reports the stand-alone average as $36 a month — a different methodology, not a different fact 5. On both paths, Part D out-of-pocket drug spending is capped at $2,100 in 2026, and no Part D plan may charge a deductible above $615 2. The national base beneficiary premium used for penalty calculations is $38.99 a month in 2026 2.

A Medigap policy is the most expensive piece of the Original Medicare path. The most recent average premium available is $217 a month — but that figure is from 2023, and there is no verified average for 2026 5. Do not trust any site that quotes a 2026 Medigap average; none has been verified. The shape of the cost: Original Medicare plus Medigap plus a stand-alone Part D plan runs roughly $420 a month, against roughly $203 a month for a $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan. That gap is the reason Medicare Advantage keeps growing.

Question 1: How bad could a bad year get?

A hospital bill and a calculator on a table showing how medical costs add up in a bad year.
A hospital bill and a calculator on a table showing how medical costs add up in a bad year.

This is the question that matters most, and the one people think about least while they are healthy. A good year looks cheap on either path. A bad year is where they split apart.

Original Medicare has no annual out-of-pocket maximum. After the $283 Part B deductible, you usually pay 20 percent of the Medicare-approved amount for most Part B services, and that 20 percent has no ceiling 1. A serious illness or a long course of outpatient treatment can leave you with a bill that keeps growing. The Part A deductible can also repeat: it applies per benefit period, not per year, so two separate hospital stays in one year can mean two $1,736 deductibles.

Medicare Advantage has a ceiling, and the ceiling is set by law. In 2026, a plan's in-network out-of-pocket maximum may not exceed $9,250, and the combined in-network and out-of-network limit may not exceed $13,900 4. Most plans set their limit lower: the enrollment-weighted average in-network maximum among enrollees in 2026 is $5,421, with about 13 percent in plans at $3,000 or less and 19 percent in plans over $7,000 4. One secondary source still quotes $9,350 as the 2026 cap — that was the 2025 figure. The 2026 ceiling is $9,250.

But the cap covers Part A and Part B services only: Part D drug spending has its own separate $2,100 cap in 2026, so a bad year can cost you the plan's medical maximum plus up to $2,100 in drug costs. And the cap belongs to the plan, not to you — if your plan's network or drug list changes next year, your costs change with it.

Original Medicare plus Medigap answers the bad-year question differently. A Medigap policy fills the gaps Parts A and B leave open — mainly the Part B deductible, the 20 percent coinsurance, and the Part A hospital coinsurance — so a bad year costs you the premiums you already paid and very little else. That is why the Medigap question, covered below, is really about whether you can still buy that protection when you need it.

Using averages, and labeling them as illustrative: in a healthy year, Medicare Advantage often wins on monthly cash: Part B at $202.90 plus a $0 plan premium for three in four drug-plan enrollees, against Original Medicare plus Medigap at roughly $217 a month on the 2023 average plus a stand-alone Part D plan at roughly $34.50 to $36 a month. In a bad year, Original Medicare alone is uncapped; Original Medicare plus Medigap caps your exposure through the supplement; and Medicare Advantage caps it at the plan's out-of-pocket maximum — $5,421 on average in-network, $9,250 at worst in-network, and $13,900 combined, plus up to $2,100 for Part D drugs. There is no single "total annual cost" winner: the honest answer depends on the plan's maximum, whether your doctors are in the network, and whether your drugs are on the plan's list.

Question 2: Do your doctors and drugs fit in a network?

The second question is about freedom, and it is the one people feel most sharply after they enroll. Original Medicare lets you see any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare, anywhere in the United States, and in most cases you need no referral and no prior authorization 6. If you spend months a year in another state, your coverage travels with you. If the best specialist for a rare condition is two states away, you can go.

Medicare Advantage plans use networks. You may need to use providers in the plan's service area, and care outside the network can cost more or may not be covered at all, depending on the plan type 6. HMO plans generally do not cover out-of-network care except in emergencies; PPO plans cover it at a higher cost. Plans may also require a referral from your primary care doctor before you see a specialist, and prior authorization — the plan's approval in advance — before certain services, such as a hospital stay 6. Our guide to HMO vs PPO explains how the two plan types differ.

This is the real trade-off behind the lower premium: you are accepting a gatekeeper. For a healthy person who sees one doctor and takes one prescription, the gate is rarely felt. For a person with a chronic condition, a trusted specialist, or a complex drug regimen, it can matter every month. Before you enroll, check every doctor you see, every drug you take, and every facility you might need against the plan's network and drug list — not just the brochure. Both change every year, and the plan that covered your cardiologist last year may not cover them this year.

The extra benefits are real, and they are part of why people choose Medicare Advantage. In 2026, 99 percent of individual Medicare Advantage plans offer vision benefits, 98 percent offer dental, and 98 percent offer hearing, measured as a share of plans rather than a share of enrollees, and about 93 percent offer a fitness benefit 4. But some extras are shrinking: an over-the-counter drug allowance is offered by 66 percent of plans, down from 73 percent in 2025, a meal benefit by 57 percent, down from 65 percent, and a transportation benefit by 24 percent, down from 30 percent 4. Treat the extras as a bonus, not the reason to choose a plan. A dental benefit does not help if your oncologist is out of network.

There are about 5,600 Medicare Advantage plans in 2026, down slightly from 5,633 in 2025, and 99 percent of beneficiaries have access to at least one; the average beneficiary can choose among plans from 8 parent organizations 4. Two companies dominate: UnitedHealth covers 26 percent of enrollees and Humana 20 percent, together 46 percent of the market 3.

Question 3: Are you closing the Medigap door?

A calendar with a six-month window circled in red, representing the Medigap open enrollment period.
A calendar with a six-month window circled in red, representing the Medigap open enrollment period.

This is the question with the longest consequences, and the one most people never hear until it is too late. You cannot use Medigap with a Medicare Advantage plan: a Medigap policy cannot pay Medicare Advantage copays, deductibles, coinsurance, or premiums, and it is illegal for anyone to sell you one while you have Medicare Advantage coverage, except when you are switching back to Original Medicare 6. You have to choose one path or the other.

The door that matters is the Medigap open enrollment period: a one-time six-month window starting the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B 6. During that window, an insurer cannot deny you a policy or charge you more because of a health problem. After it closes, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting — asking health questions, denying you, or charging more based on your health 6.

That is the lock-in. If you choose Medicare Advantage at 65 and develop a serious condition at 70, you can switch back to Original Medicare during open enrollment — that part is always available. But buying a Medigap policy to cover Original Medicare's uncapped 20 percent coinsurance may no longer be possible at a price you can afford, or at all, because you are now outside your one-time window and your health has changed. You would be back in Original Medicare with no cap and no supplement, the most exposed position in the program.

There is a narrow safety net: a 12-month trial right. If you join a Medicare Advantage plan when you first become eligible at 65, or drop a Medigap policy to try one for the first time, and you switch back to Original Medicare within that first year, you have a guaranteed right to buy a Medigap policy without medical underwriting 6. If you dropped a Medigap policy, you can generally get your old policy back if the same company still sells it. After the 12 months expire, the federal protection is gone. A few states add their own protections, but most do not — check your state's rules before you assume you can get back in.

Three people, three answers

The three questions land differently for different lives. Here are three sketches, labeled as illustrations.

The healthy 68-year-old who rarely sees a doctor. She takes one generic prescription and sees her primary care doctor twice a year. Medicare Advantage is often the better fit: a $0-premium plan, a $5,421 average in-network out-of-pocket maximum as a safety net, and dental and vision benefits she will actually use. She should still re-check the network and the drug list every fall, because both change.

The snowbird who splits the year between two states. He spends winters in Florida and summers in Ohio, with a cardiologist in each place. Original Medicare is usually the better fit: it travels with him, and any doctor who takes Medicare in either state can treat him with no referral and usually no prior authorization 6. A Medicare Advantage plan would leave him out of network for half the year. If he wants cost protection, Medigap bought during his six-month window is the answer.

The person with a chronic condition and a trusted specialist. She has rheumatoid arthritis, sees a rheumatologist she has trusted for a decade, and takes a specialty drug that costs thousands of dollars a month. Her first check is whether that specialist and that drug are in the plan's network and formulary, and what prior authorization requires. If the specialist is out of network or the drug needs repeated approvals, Original Medicare plus Medigap and a Part D plan is usually the better fit, even at higher premiums — because a disrupted treatment plan costs more. If the specialist is in network and the drug is covered with manageable rules, a Medicare Advantage plan with a low out-of-pocket maximum can work.

When you can switch

Medicare open enrollment, also called the Annual Election Period, runs October 15 to December 7 each year, and changes take effect January 1 6. During that window, anyone can move between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage, or change Medicare Advantage or Part D plans.

The Medicare Advantage open enrollment period runs January 1 to March 31 each year 6. During that window, people already in a Medicare Advantage plan may make one change: switch to another Medicare Advantage plan, or drop Medicare Advantage and return to Original Medicare, joining a Part D plan if they wish.

Enrollment window When What you can do
Medicare open enrollment October 15 to December 7 Move between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage; change Medicare Advantage or Part D plans; changes start January 1
Medicare Advantage open enrollment January 1 to March 31 If you are in Medicare Advantage, make one change: switch plans or return to Original Medicare
Medigap open enrollment Six months starting the month you turn 65 and enroll in Part B Buy any Medigap policy with no medical underwriting; one-time only
Trial right First 12 months in Medicare Advantage Return to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap policy without underwriting

Review your coverage every fall during open enrollment, even if you are happy with your plan. Medicare Advantage added 1.1 million enrollees from 2025 to 2026, growth of about 3 percent, and 23 percent of enrollees — about 8.2 million people — are now in Special Needs Plans, which accounted for 85 percent of the net increase 3. The Congressional Budget Office projects the Medicare Advantage share will reach 63 percent by 2034 3.

Checklist before you enroll

  1. Every doctor. Is each doctor you see in the plan's network? Call the office and ask, because directories go stale.
  2. Every drug. Is each prescription on the plan's formulary, at what tier, and does it need prior authorization? Remember the Part D $2,100 cap and the plan's deductible, which can be up to $615.
  3. The out-of-pocket maximum. What is this plan's in-network limit — not the $9,250 federal ceiling, but the plan's own number? The average is $5,421, but your plan's number decides your worst year.
  4. The Evidence of Coverage. This is the plan's full contract. Read the sections on prior authorization, referrals, and out-of-network care before you enroll.
  5. Your travel. Do you spend months in another state? Original Medicare travels; a Medicare Advantage plan's network usually does not.
  6. The Medigap clock. Are you inside your six-month Medigap open enrollment window? If so, and there is any chance you will want Medigap later, this is the cheapest moment in your life to buy it.

Verified against CMS and KFF on November 15, 2026.

The bottom line

In 2026, 55 percent of eligible Medicare beneficiaries — 35.2 million people — are in Medicare Advantage, and the choice comes down to three questions. How bad could a bad year get? Medicare Advantage caps your in-network medical spending at $9,250 by law, $5,421 on average, while Original Medicare has no cap at all — unless a Medigap policy covers the gap. Do your doctors and drugs fit in a network? Original Medicare lets you see any doctor who takes Medicare anywhere in the country, usually without referrals or prior authorization, while Medicare Advantage plans use networks and may require both. And are you closing the Medigap door? Your one-time six-month Medigap window starts when you turn 65 and join Part B, and once it closes, insurers in most states can deny you or charge more. You pay the $202.90 Part B premium on both paths, and three in four Medicare Advantage drug-plan enrollees pay no plan premium beyond it. Pick the path that fits your health, your doctors, and your tolerance for risk — and review it every fall.

Frequently asked questions

Is Medicare Advantage better than Original Medicare?
Neither is better for everyone. Medicare Advantage usually costs less month to month, caps your yearly spending, and adds dental, vision, and hearing benefits — but you must stay in a network and may need referrals and prior authorization. Original Medicare costs more in premiums and has no out-of-pocket cap, but you can see any doctor who takes Medicare anywhere in the country. The right choice depends on your health, your doctors, and how much financial risk you can carry.
Can I switch from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare?
Yes, during Medicare open enrollment from October 15 to December 7 each year, with the change taking effect January 1, or during the Medicare Advantage open enrollment period from January 1 to March 31. Leaving Medicare Advantage is the easy part. Getting a Medigap policy to cover Original Medicare's gaps is the hard part, because after your one-time six-month window, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting to deny you or charge more.
Can I have Medigap and Medicare Advantage at the same time?
No. A Medigap policy cannot pay Medicare Advantage copays, deductibles, coinsurance, or premiums, and it is illegal for anyone to sell you a Medigap policy while you have Medicare Advantage coverage, except when you are switching back to Original Medicare. You have to choose one path or the other.
What is the Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum for 2026?
For 2026, the federal ceiling is $9,250 for in-network services and $13,900 for in-network and out-of-network services combined. Most plans set their limit lower: the enrollment-weighted average in-network maximum among Medicare Advantage enrollees in 2026 is $5,421. Always check the specific plan's limit, because it is the plan's number — not the federal ceiling — that decides what you pay.
Do I still pay the Part B premium with Medicare Advantage?
Yes. You pay the standard Part B premium of $202.90 a month in 2026 on both paths, plus any premium your Medicare Advantage plan charges. Three in four Medicare Advantage drug-plan enrollees pay no plan premium beyond Part B, and some plans even pay back part of your Part B premium.
Does Medicare Advantage require prior authorization or referrals?
It may. Medicare Advantage plans can require you to get approval before certain services, such as hospital stays, and can require a referral from your primary care doctor to see a specialist, depending on the plan type. Original Medicare usually requires neither. Before you enroll, check the plan's rules for the services you use most.

Sources

Numbers in the text point to these publications. Links open the original source.

  1. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). 2026 Medicare Parts A & B Premiums and Deductibles
  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). 2026 Medicare Part D Bid Information and Part D Premium Stabilization Demonstration Parameters
  3. KFF. Medicare Advantage in 2026: Enrollment Update and Key Trends
  4. KFF. Medicare Advantage 2026 Spotlight: A First Look at Plan Premiums and Benefits
  5. KFF. How Much Do People with Medicare Pay for Coverage?
  6. Medicare.gov (CMS). Compare Original Medicare & Medicare Advantage

Back to the main health insurance guide

This guide is general educational information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Insurance rules and prices vary by state, company and personal circumstances. Confirm anything important with your state insurance department or a licensed professional. Read the full disclaimer.