Help Insurance

Health Insurance, basics

How to Appeal a Denied Health Insurance Claim: Internal Appeals and External Review

Insurers denied 19% of in-network claims in 2024, and fewer than 1% of denied claims were ever appealed. The appeal process exists for a reason — here is how it works, step by step.

Published
Updated
Reading time
16 min read

Key takeaways

  • Your insurer must tell you in writing why it denied the claim: within 15 days for a prior-authorization request, 30 days for services already received, and 72 hours for urgent care.
  • You have 180 days from the denial notice to file an internal appeal, and the insurer must finish it within 30 days for care not yet received or 60 days for care already received.
  • If the internal appeal fails, you can ask for an external review within 4 months of the final denial; a standard review is decided within 45 days and an expedited one within 72 hours.
  • In 2024, HealthCare.gov insurers denied 19% of in-network claims, yet fewer than 1% of denied claims were appealed — and insurers upheld 66% of the denials they reviewed on appeal.
  • Your insurer must accept the external reviewer's decision, and any fee for an external review cannot be more than $25.
In this guide
A person reading a health insurance denial letter at a kitchen table with a pen and paperwork.
A person reading a health insurance denial letter at a kitchen table with a pen and paperwork.

A denied health insurance claim feels final. It is not. The law gives you the right to challenge the decision, first with your insurer and then with an independent reviewer — and the numbers show how rarely people use that right. In 2024, insurers selling qualified health plans on HealthCare.gov denied 19% of in-network claims and 37% of out-of-network claims, for a combined average of 20% of all claims 5. Yet fewer than 1% of denied claims were ever appealed, and when people did appeal, insurers upheld 66% of the denials they reviewed 5.

That last number cuts both ways. It means an appeal often fails — but it also means about a third of appealed denials were overturned. And the appeal rate itself is the real story: fewer than one in a hundred denied claims gets challenged at all. Many denials are simple mistakes — a wrong code, a missing form, a service that was actually covered — and those are the cases most likely to be fixed on appeal. This guide explains the process in order: what the denial letter must tell you, how the internal appeal works, what to put in your letter, and how to ask for an external review when the insurer says no a second time.

Why claims get denied

Before you appeal, it helps to know what you are up against. Insurers report reasons for denials, and the most common ones are not what most people expect. In 2024, the largest share of in-network denials — 36% — was listed under "Other," a reason that tells you almost nothing 5. Administrative reasons came next at 25%: claims that were duplicated, missing information, filed late, or sent to an unapproved provider 5. Nine percent of denials were for lack of prior authorization or a referral, and only 5% were for lack of medical necessity 5. Another 13% were for a service the plan excludes 5.

Read that list again, because it shapes your strategy. A quarter of denials are administrative, which means a missing form, a coding error, or a late filing — problems that can often be fixed with a phone call or a corrected claim rather than a formal appeal. Only 5% are denials on medical necessity, the kind of denial that needs a doctor's letter and a real argument. And more than a third are labeled "Other," which means the denial letter itself may not explain the reason clearly — and the law says it has to.

Denial rates also vary widely by insurer. In 2024, in-network denial rates for HealthCare.gov insurers ranged from 3% to 36% 5. Some insurers deny far more often than others. That does not change your appeal rights, but it does mean a denial from a high-denial insurer is not proof that your care was unreasonable. It is proof that the insurer denies a lot.

Step 0: read the denial letter carefully

Everything starts with the letter — or, if the claim was for a service already received, the explanation of benefits that says the claim was denied. Federal rule 45 CFR 147.136 requires the plan to tell you in writing why it denied the claim, how to appeal, and how to ask for an external review 4. If the letter does not explain the reason in words you can understand, that is itself a problem, and you should ask the insurer for a clearer explanation in writing.

Your insurer must also send the notice on a deadline. It must notify you in writing and explain why within 15 days for a prior-authorization request, within 30 days for services already received, and within 72 hours for urgent care 1. If the insurer misses its own deadline, note the date — a late notice can matter in an appeal, and in some cases you may be able to go straight to an external review.

When the letter arrives, read it with a pen and mark four things. First, the reason given for the denial, in the insurer's own words. Second, the claim number and the date of service. Third, the deadline to appeal, which the letter must state. Fourth, the name and contact details of the appeals department, and whether the plan uses a state or federal external review process. State rules set different deadlines for external review, so the letter's exact deadline is the one that counts for you — do not rely on a single number from a national guide.

Then check the reason against your plan documents. Look up the service in your plan's summary of benefits and coverage and in the full plan document. If the plan covers the service and the denial says otherwise, you have found the core of your appeal. If the plan excludes the service, your appeal will need a different argument — usually that the service is medically necessary and the exclusion was applied wrongly, or that the insurer's own rules were not followed. Either way, do not appeal on a hunch. Appeal on the documents.

Step 1: fix the simple problems first

Not every denial needs a formal appeal. If the denial reason is administrative — a missing form, a wrong code, a claim sent to the wrong address — a phone call to the insurer or to your provider's billing office may fix it faster than an appeal. Ask the provider to check the claim for coding errors and to resubmit it with the correction. Ask the insurer exactly what document or code is missing.

Also check whether prior authorization was the problem. If the denial says the service needed prior authorization and none was obtained, find out whether your doctor requested it and what happened to the request. Sometimes the authorization was requested and approved but never linked to the claim. Sometimes it was denied and no one told you. The fix differs in each case, and you need to know which one you are dealing with before you write the appeal.

If the problem is not fixable with a call, or if the insurer will not fix it, move to the formal internal appeal. Do not wait: the clock is running, and the 180-day deadline counts from the date you received the denial notice.

Step 2: the internal appeal

The internal appeal is the first formal step. You ask your own insurer to look at the denial again, and a different person inside the company reviews it. You must file an internal appeal within 180 days — 6 months — of receiving the denial notice 1. That is a generous window compared with most insurance deadlines, but it still passes quickly when you are also dealing with treatment, work, and bills. Start the week you get the letter, not in month five.

The insurer must complete the internal appeal within 30 days if the service has not yet been received, or within 60 days if the service was already received 1. Those are the maximums. For urgent care, the timeline is much shorter: the insurer must decide a prior-authorization request within 72 hours 1. If your health would be seriously harmed by waiting, say so in writing, use the word "urgent," and ask for an expedited review.

Step Deadline
Insurer's written denial notice, prior authorization 15 days
Insurer's written denial notice, services already received 30 days
Insurer's written denial notice, urgent care 72 hours
You file the internal appeal Within 180 days of the denial notice
Insurer completes the internal appeal, care not yet received Within 30 days
Insurer completes the internal appeal, care already received Within 60 days
You request an external review Within 4 months of the final denial
Standard external review decision Within 45 days of the request
Expedited external review decision Within 72 hours

How you file matters as much as what you file. Send the appeal in writing — by the insurer's online portal, by mail, or by fax — and keep proof that you sent it: a confirmation number, a certified mail receipt, or a fax confirmation page. Do not rely on a phone call alone to start an appeal, because a phone call leaves no record of the date. If the insurer's portal gives you a reference number, save it. If you mail the letter, send it certified mail with a return receipt. Deadlines are decided by dates, and dates are decided by proof.

Ask your doctor for help early. A letter of medical necessity from the doctor who ordered the care is the single most useful document in a medical-necessity appeal, and doctors write them routinely. Give the doctor the denial letter, the plan's stated reason, and a short note about what the letter should address: why this treatment is needed for your condition, what alternatives were tried and why they did not work, and what the medical guidelines say. A letter that answers the insurer's specific reason is far stronger than a generic note.

What to put in the appeal letter

A good appeal letter is short, specific, and built around the plan's own words. Keep it to one or two pages, and include these pieces:

  • Your identification and the claim. Your full name, date of birth, member ID, the claim number, the date of service, the provider's name, and the amount in dispute. The reviewer handles hundreds of cases; make yours easy to find.
  • The plan's stated reason. Quote the denial reason exactly as the letter gives it. Then answer it directly: if the denial says the service is not medically necessary, explain why it is, with the doctor's letter attached. If it says prior authorization was missing, attach the authorization or explain why none was required. If it says the service is excluded, point to the part of the plan document that covers it.
  • A letter of medical necessity. From the doctor who ordered the care, addressing the insurer's reason, the alternatives tried, and the guidelines that support the treatment.
  • The medical records that support it. Lab results, imaging, visit notes, and the treatment history that show why the care was needed. Do not send your entire chart — send the pages that matter and list them in the letter.
  • The plan language. A copy of the relevant pages from your plan document or summary of benefits that show the service is covered, or that show the exclusion the insurer cited does not apply to your case.
  • What you are asking for. State plainly that you are asking the insurer to reverse the denial and pay the claim, and give the amount.
  • A peer-to-peer review request. If the denial was based on medical necessity, ask for a peer-to-peer review: a conversation between your doctor and the insurer's medical reviewer. Many denials are overturned in that conversation, because it lets the treating doctor explain the case to a clinician rather than to a form.

Write the letter in your own voice but keep the tone factual. The reviewer is not your enemy, and anger does not help the case. Facts, dates, and documents do. End the letter by asking for written confirmation that the appeal was received, and note the date by which the insurer must decide.

Step 3: the external review

If the internal appeal fails, you are not finished. You can request an external review, in which an independent third party — someone who works for neither you nor the insurer — looks at the case and decides it. File a written request within 4 months of receiving the final denial 3 2. A standard external review is decided no later than 45 days after the request, and an expedited external review is decided no later than 72 hours 3 2. Your insurer is required by law to accept the external reviewer's decision, and any fee charged for the review cannot be more than $25 3 2.

The external review is the step most people never hear about, and it is the most powerful one you have. The reviewer is independent, the decision binds the insurer, and the fee is capped at $25 — many states charge nothing. In 2024, Marketplace enrollees filed at least 5,881 external appeals, or 4% of all upheld internal appeals 5. That number is small, and it is small partly because so few people know the step exists. A KFF survey found that only 40% of consumers believed they had a legal right to appeal to a government agency or an independent medical expert, while 51% said they were unsure and 9% did not believe they had the right 5.

In urgent situations you can request an external review at the same time as the internal appeal, rather than waiting for the internal appeal to finish 1. This matters when delay would seriously harm your health: do not wait out a 30-day internal appeal for care you need this week. Say in writing that the situation is urgent and ask for both reviews at once.

How you file an external review depends on your state and your plan. Some states run their own external review process, and some use the federal process run by the Department of Health and Human Services. The federal HHS-administered external review process takes requests by phone at 1-888-866-6205 4. Your denial letter should say which process applies to you and give the contact details. If it does not, call your state insurance department — or the insurer — and ask. State-specific deadlines vary, so the denial letter's exact deadline is the one to follow rather than any single number in a national guide.

When you file, send the same package you sent for the internal appeal, plus the internal appeal's final denial letter. The external reviewer reads the whole record, including the insurer's reasoning, and decides whether the denial was correct under the plan and under the law. Because the reviewer is independent, the quality of your medical records and your doctor's letter matters more than it did at the internal stage — this is a fresh look, not a rubber stamp.

Medicare and Medicaid paths

The process above covers private plans, including Marketplace plans. Medicare and Medicaid have their own appeal processes, with their own deadlines, and the details differ from the private-plan rules.

For Medicare Advantage, you have 65 days from the date on the denial notice to appeal 3. That is a different number from the 180 days for a private plan, and it is shorter, so check the date on the notice the day it arrives. Original Medicare has its own multi-level appeal process, starting with a redetermination by the contractor that processed the claim. The notice you receive explains the level and the deadline, and the same advice applies: start early, keep copies, and get your doctor's support in writing.

Medicaid appeals also follow state rules, and the deadlines and the office that handles them vary by state. If Medicaid denies a service, the denial notice tells you how to ask for a hearing and how long you have. Many states also offer help from a patient advocate or a legal aid office at no cost. If the amount is large or the care is urgent, that help is worth seeking early rather than after a deadline passes.

Whatever the program, the habits are the same: read the notice the day it arrives, note the deadline in writing, keep a copy of everything you send, and do not assume the first no is the last word.

Mistakes that cost people their appeal

A person organizing insurance paperwork and appeal documents in labeled folders on a desk.
A person organizing insurance paperwork and appeal documents in labeled folders on a desk.

Most lost appeals are lost on process, not on the merits. The common mistakes are easy to avoid once you know them.

Missing the deadline. The 180 days for an internal appeal and the 4 months for an external review are hard limits. Mark both dates on a calendar the day the denial arrives, and file at least a week early in case something goes wrong with the portal or the mail.

Appealing by phone only. A phone call can get information, but it does not create a record. Always follow up in writing, keep the confirmation, and keep a copy of what you sent.

Sending the appeal without the doctor's letter. A denial based on medical necessity is almost impossible to overturn without a letter of medical necessity. Get it before you file, not after.

Appealing the wrong reason. If the denial says the claim was coded wrong, a letter arguing medical necessity will not help. Answer the reason the insurer actually gave, not the reason you wish it had given.

Giving up after the internal appeal. The internal appeal is reviewed by the same company that denied the claim. The external review is independent, and the insurer must accept its decision. Most people who win, win at the external stage — and most people never get there, because they stop after the first no.

Paying a bill you are still appealing. If the provider is billing you while the appeal is pending, tell the provider in writing that the claim is under appeal and ask them to pause collection. Many providers will wait.

When to get help

You can handle most appeals yourself, and most people do. But some cases are worth getting help for. If the amount is large, if the care is urgent, or if the insurer has denied the claim twice, consider a patient advocate. Many hospitals have one on staff, and many states fund consumer assistance programs that help with appeals for free. Your state insurance department can also step in: it regulates the insurer, takes complaints, and in some states can help resolve a dispute directly.

Legal help is rarely needed at the internal appeal stage, but a lawyer who works on insurance denials can be worth consulting if the external review fails and the amount is large. Many such lawyers work on contingency for big claims, and a short consultation is often free. Legal aid offices help low-income patients with Medicaid and Marketplace denials at no cost.

One more source of help is your provider. Doctors and hospitals appeal denials every day, and their billing offices often know exactly which form, code, or letter will fix a given denial. Ask the provider whether they will appeal on your behalf — many will, especially for a service they ordered and believe is necessary.

A patient advocate on the phone reviewing an insurance appeal while looking at a laptop.
A patient advocate on the phone reviewing an insurance appeal while looking at a laptop.

Keep a file, and keep it from day one

Start a folder — paper or digital — the day the first denial arrives, and put everything in it. The denial letter, the explanation of benefits, the claim number, the plan documents, the doctor's letter, the medical records you sent, the confirmation that your appeal was received, and every letter the insurer sends back. Write the date on each document as it arrives. If you call the insurer, write down the date, the name of the person you spoke to, and what they said, and follow up in writing.

This sounds like busywork until the moment it is not. Appeals are decided on the record, and the record is the pile of paper you kept. A missing confirmation or an undated letter can cost you a deadline dispute. A complete file, kept from day one, turns a stressful process into a manageable one.

Verified against HealthCare.gov's internal and external appeals pages, KFF's "Claims Denials and Appeals in ACA Marketplace Plans in 2024," and the appeals guidance from MesoCare and Black Health on November 20, 2026.

The bottom line

A denied claim is the start of a process, not the end of one. Your insurer must explain the denial in writing, and you have 180 days to file an internal appeal that it must finish within 30 or 60 days. If that fails, ask for an external review within 4 months: an independent reviewer decides, the insurer must accept the decision, and the fee cannot be more than $25. In 2024, insurers denied 19% of in-network claims, yet fewer than 1% of denied claims were appealed — and about a third of the appeals that were filed succeeded. Before you pay a denied bill, check the reason, fix the simple errors, get a letter of medical necessity from your doctor, and use every step the law gives you. The appeal exists because denials are often wrong, and the only way to find out is to file one.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to appeal a denied health insurance claim?
You must file an internal appeal within 180 days — 6 months — of receiving the denial notice. If the internal appeal fails, you generally have 4 months from the final denial to request an external review. State rules can set different deadlines, so the denial letter states the exact one that applies to you.
What is the difference between an internal appeal and an external review?
An internal appeal asks your own insurer to look at the denial again. An external review sends the case to an independent third party who was not involved in the first decision. Your insurer is required by law to accept the external reviewer's decision.
How long does an internal appeal take?
The insurer must complete an internal appeal within 30 days if the service has not been received yet, or within 60 days if the service was already received. For urgent care, the insurer must decide a prior-authorization request within 72 hours.
How much does an external review cost?
Any fee charged for an external review cannot be more than $25. Many states charge no fee at all. The insurer pays the cost of the review itself, and it must accept the reviewer's decision even if the decision goes against the insurer.
What should I include in my appeal letter?
Include your claim number, the date of service, the name of the provider, the plan's stated reason for the denial, and a short, clear statement of why the care should be covered. Attach a letter of medical necessity from your doctor, the relevant medical records, and any part of your plan documents that supports coverage.
Can I ask for an external review and an internal appeal at the same time?
In urgent situations, yes — you can request an external review at the same time as the internal appeal, instead of waiting for the internal appeal to finish. For non-urgent care, you usually complete the internal appeal first and then ask for an external review.

Sources

Numbers in the text point to these publications. Links open the original source.

  1. HealthCare.gov. Internal appeals
  2. HealthCare.gov. External Review
  3. MesoCare. Your Insurance Said No: How to Appeal a Denial (2026)
  4. Black Health. Denied by Your Health Insurer? How to Appeal, State by State
  5. KFF. Claims Denials and Appeals in ACA Marketplace Plans in 2024

Back to the main health insurance guide

This guide is general educational information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Insurance rules and prices vary by state, company and personal circumstances. Confirm anything important with your state insurance department or a licensed professional. Read the full disclaimer.